Each movie listed includes: 

(1) Title (2) Rating (3) Genres (4) Starring (5) Synopsis (6) My Personal Review (7) Scoring 1-5

 

 Click on the pictures to pin them on Pinterest for later.

Santa Baby (2006)
Rated: PG
Genres: Comedy, Family, Fantasy, Romance 
Starring: Jenny McCarthy, Ivan Sergei, and George Wendt 
Synopsis: Mary Class is a highly successful business executive - who just happens to be the daughter of Santa Claus. But when her father falls ill, Mary returns to the North Pole and the life she left behind to take over for her dad and implement her innovative ideas for running Christmas.
Review:  If you can get past the idea that Santa, supposedly immortal, has heart issues and needs recovery time, you’ll love it. The elves are funny and you want Mary to bridge the traditional with the modern and succeed. 
Scoring: 4
Santa Baby 2: Christmas Maybe (2009)
Rated: PG
Genres: Comedy, Family, Fantasy, Romance 
Starring: Jenny McCarthy, Dean McDermott, and Paul Sorvino
Synopsis: Santa's in the midst of a "late-life" crisis--he's tired of the responsibilities of the job and he's ready to let his business-minded daughter, Mary, take over. Mary feels torn between the family business, running her own high stakes firm in New York City, and balancing a relationship with Luke. The situation gets even more stressful when Teri, a mysterious and ambitious new-comer to the Pole, decides that she wants to be the new Santa. Can Mary get this straightened out in time to save Christmas?
Review:  I liked this a lot less than the first one. It has the same lighthearted vibe but I have a few problems with it. We have a different Luke and a different Santa. I don’t buy Paul Sorvino as Santa. We’ve been shown that elves are senseless yet one elf is bright enough to trick Santa, Mrs. Claus, Mary, and Luke. I enjoyed it but not as much. 
Scoring: 3

Santa Buddies (2009)

Rated: G

Genres: Adventure, Family, Fantasy 

Starring: Danny Woodburn, Tom Bosley, Richard Kind, Christopher Lloyd, George Wendt, and Tim Conway 

Synopsis: When Puppy Paws (the fun-loving son of Santa Paws) gets bored, he finds Budderball on Santa's naughty list and figures he's just the dog to show him how to be an ordinary pup. When the magical Christmas Icicle starts to melt however, and the world begins to forget the true meaning of the season, it's up to Puppy Paws and his newfound Buddies to journey back to the North Pole and save Christmas.

Review:  Yet another talking animal movie. I found it to be beyond silly but the dogs are cute. I’d put this in the for kids not adults column. 

Scoring: 2

Santa Claus Conquers The Martians (1964)

Rated: PG

Genres: Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy 

Starring: Pia Zadora 

Synopsis: The Martians kidnap Santa Claus because there is nobody on Mars to give their children presents.

Review:  If you like poorly made circa 1960s/1970s sci-fi, you may enjoy this but you’ll probably be the only one. It’s so absurd. The story, acting, effects, and costumes are ridiculous. This can’t even count as “it’s so bad it’s good”. It’s just bad. 

Scoring: 1

Santa Claus The Movie (1984)
Rated: PG
Genres: Drama, Fantasy 
Starring: Dudley Moore and John Lithgow
Synopsis: This is the story of a master toymaker who discovers a magical kingdom of elves in the North Pole and becomes Santa Claus. But when Santa's eager-to-please elf Patch leaves the North Pole for the big streets of New York City, he becomes mixed up with a dastardly toy tycoon's plans to take over Christmas. And so begins Santa's adventure - to rescue his faithful elf and to save Christmas for all the children of the world!
Review:  A classic for me that we watch every year. It shows a magical side of Santa and his elves in a unique way.  This is a realistic looking Santa.
Scoring: 3
 
The Santa Clause (1994)
Rated: PG
Genres: Comedy, Drama, Family, Fantasy 
Starring: Tim Allen, Judge Reinhold, Wendy Crewson, Eric Lloyd, and David Krumholtz
Synopsis: When a man inadvertently kills Santa on Christmas Eve, he finds himself magically recruited to take his place.
Review:  I love this movie but I’m still bothered by the fact that the immortal Santa can be killed and replaced. I guess that’s my inner child freaking out. Other than that, it’s a magical North Pole, and interesting transition from man to Santa, loving moments, and lots of fun. 
Scoring: 4
 
The Santa Clause 2 (2002)
Rated: G
Genres: Comedy, Drama, Family, Fantasy, Romance 
Starring:  Tim Allen, Judge Reinhold, Wendy Crewson, Eric Lloyd, David Krumholtz, Spencer Breslin, Elizabeth Mitchell, Aisha Tyler, Kevin Pollack, Jay Thomas, Art LaFleur, Peter Boyle, and Molly Shannon
Synopsis: Scott Calvin has been Santa Claus for the past eight years, and his loyal elves consider him the best Santa ever. But Santa's got problems (he's even mysteriously losing weight) and things quickly go south when he finds out that his son, Charlie, has landed on this year's "naughty" list. Desperate to help his son, Scott heads back home, leaving a substitute Claus to watch over things at the Pole. But when the substitute institutes some strange redefinitions of naughty and nice, putting Christmas at risk, it's up to Scott to return with a new bag of magic to try to save Christmas.
Review:  Similar fun and magic to the first movie but the plastic Claus scenes were a little much. 
Scoring: 3
 
The Santa Clause 3 (2006)
Rated: G
Genres: Comedy, Drama, Family, Fantasy, Romance 
Starring: Tim Allen, Judge Reinhold, Wendy Crewson, Eric Lloyd, Spencer Breslin, Elizabeth Mitchell, Aisha Tyler, Kevin Pollack, Jay Thomas, Martin Short, Ann Margaret, Alan Arkin, Art LaFleur, and Peter Boyle
Synopsis: Santa's got problems: it's a few days before Christmas and production lags, Mrs. Claus is about to give birth to their first child and wants family time, and Jack Frost (tired of second billing) is on probation under his supervision. He tries to support his wife by bringing her parents to the North Pole (to preserve his secret, they must think it's Canada). He also brings his ex-wife Laura, her husband Neil, and their daughter Lucy. Inside the toy factory, Jack makes mischief and hatches a plan to become Santa. With Santa juggling that many snow globes, something is bound to go wrong. But if things get too difficult, he can always exercise his option to invoke the Escape Clause. Will he?
Review:  Truly one of a kind look at Santa. It still has the emotion and humor of the first two but adding the family to the North Pole is lots of fun. 
Scoring: 4
 

Santa Claws (2014)

Rated: PG

Genres: Family, Fantasy

Starring: Ezra James Colbert

 Synopsis: Tommy, who is unable to celebrate Christmas because his mom says Santa isn't real, leaves his kittens out for Santa to take back to the North Pole, but after a major allergic reaction Santa can't fly the sleigh or deliver presents anymore, so the kittens have to deliver the rest of the presents to all the boys and girls before sunrise.

Review: This movie was so hard to sit through. It’s so insipid. Small children may like the cats but that’s it.

Scoring: 1

The Santa Con (2014)
Rated: NR
Genres: Comedy, Drama, Family, Romance 
Starring: Barry Watson, Melissa Sagemiller, Melissa Joan Hart, Jaleel White, and John Ratzenberger 
Synopsis: Small-time con man Nick is ordered by his parole officer to take a minimum-wage job as a department store Santa during the holidays and he hates it. Near the end of his first shift, he hastily promises a young boy, Billy, that Santa will bring his estranged parents back together by Christmas. When his sister Rosemary hears this, she is livid and can't believe he would break a little boy's heart with an empty promise. After a long night of soul searching - and with the help of an insightful female pastor - Nick decides to make good on his promise to the child, somehow. But after meeting the boy's mother Carol, will Nick ultimately choose to put the happiness of others ahead of his own?
Review:  It’s nice seeing the moral dilemma and the changes this situation brings about in Nick. The true meaning of the Christmas spirit comes to life. 
Scoring: 3
 

Santa Girl (2019)

Rated: PG

Genres: Comedy, Fantasy, Romance

Starring: Barry Bostwick and Jennifer Stone

Synopsis: Fleeing the family business and an arranged marriage, Santa’s daughter chooses a magical adventure of her own: college.

Review: This is blah.  Start with Mrs. Claus is dead, Santa doesn’t eat carbs, and their daughter is a lazy and spoiled brat.  That about sums up the Christmas spirit of the movie.  Of course, everything works out.  I just didn’t really care.  Maybe more of a movie for tweens.

Scoring: 2

The Santa Incident (2010)

Rated: NR

Genres: Comedy, Family 

Starring: Greg Germann and Ione Skye

Synopsis: After his sleigh is shot down while flying through restricted military airspace, an earthbound Santa is sought for questioning by a pair of overzealous Homeland Security agents. The fate of Christmas is now in the hands of the disbelieving by-the-book duo, unless their faith in Santa can be restored by two children and a trio of elves who have arrived from up North to help out a friend in need.

Review:  I found this to be a little dumb, children may enjoy the children in the movie. That is if they can handle Santa’s sleigh being shot down. This is one you can skip. 

Scoring: 1

 

Santa Jr. (2002)

Rated: NR

Genres: Comedy, Family, Romance 

Starring: Lauren Holly, Judd Nelson, and Nick Stabile

Synopsis: Father Christmas's son tries to follow in his father's footsteps, but gets arrested while delivering presents.

Review:  I’ll admit it’s a little cheesy but I think it’s a nice family film. I enjoyed the adventures and all the characters. The Christmas magic makes it even better. 

Scoring: 3

 

Santa Paws 2 (2012)

Rated: G

Genres: Adventure, Family, Fantasy

Starring: Cheryl Ladd and Pat Finn

Synopsis: When Mrs. Claus travels to Pineville, the playful Santa Pups stow away on her sled.  Taking mischief to a whole new level, they begin granting joyful wishes to Pineville's boys and girls, but something goes terribly wrong - the Christmas spirit begins to disappear. Now the Santa Pups and Mrs. Claus must race to save Christmas around the world. From the creators of Disney Buddies, this magical, heartwarming tale is brimming with hope, cheer, and Christmas spirit.

Review: While it’s yet another talking animal movie, this one is better than many others, not that that’s saying much. This one is geared towards children.

Scoring: 2

The Santa Suit (2010)

Rated: G

Genres: Drama, Fantasy 

Starring: Kevin Sorbo and Jodie Dowdall

Synopsis: Hunter Toys CEO Drake Hunter turned his father's company from a cozy quality manufacturer into a ruthless, profitable business. After denying his staff any festive generosity again, the scrooge is suddenly and magically transformed into Kris Krandall. That forces him to work as a Santa in Norm Dobson's toy store, with weird would be-actor Sebastian. Drake reassesses his values and priorities in life. 

Review:  The premise is corny but that’s it. I found this to be touching. A man learns how others see him, how to be there for others, how to empathize, and how to be a good man. I truly enjoyed watching this one. This will be an annual movie for us. 

Scoring: 4

The Santa Switch (2013)
Rated: NR
Genres: Family, Fantasy 
Starring: Ethan Erickson, Anne Dudek, and Sean Astin 
Synopsis: As the Christmas season approaches, Dan is facing unemployment, and struggling to pay for the gifts he thinks will impress his two kids, Sally and Joe. Always chasing a new business idea, Dan hasn't had time for family, and his wife Linda is filing divorce papers. Threatened by Linda's handsome and successful young boss, Trevor, Dan knows he must make this Christmas the best one yet to win his family back.  When Dan doesn’t get a mall Santa job, he blames Christmas for his problems. The real Santa visits Dan, decides to take a vacation and leaves Dan in charge with his elf, Eddie, to help guide Dan. With the sudden power to impress Linda and the kids by making every wild Christmas wish come true, Dan soon gets carried away. As the fate of the whole world's Christmas rests in his hands, can Dan focus on what his family really needs without flubbing his greatest gig yet?
Review:  This movie examines the materialism of the holidays vs. the true spirit of Christmas. We watch as Dan learns that his children need love more than things. It’s a little predictable but still mostly enjoyable. 
Scoring: 3
 

Santa Who (2000)

Rated: PG

Genres: Adventure, Comedy, Drama, Family, Fantasy, Musical 

Starring: Leslie Nielson, Steven Eckholdt, and Robin Lively

Synopsis: Santa Claus develops amnesia after accidentally falling out of his sleigh and only the innocence of a small child can save him. Meanwhile, Santa has to battle the disbelief of a newsman.

Review:  This movie is a little silly but it’s good for children and those who are a child at heart. It’s got everything you’d expect; a child, a grinch, and a Santa in need of help. 

Scoring: 3

 

Santa With Muscles (1996)

Rated: PG

Genres: Comedy

Starring: Hulk Hogan

Synopsis: An evil millionaire believes he is Santa Claus after an accident renders him amnesiac.

Review:  If you like Hogan, you may enjoy watching him. Other than that, the movie has nothing to offer. 

Scoring: 1

 

Santa’s Apprentice (2010)

Rated: G

Genres: Animation, Fantasy

Starring: N/A

Synopsis: Santa doesn't want to retire, but rules are rules and he must train someone to replace him. The lucky winner, to be chosen from among millions of children, must be named Nicholas, be an orphan and have a pure heart. On the other side of the planet, there is a little boy who is a perfect match, but his lack of self-confidence and fear of heights make him a poor contestant. Will Santa agree to step down, and help his apprentice take his place?

Review:  If you want to talk to your children about other children saying there’s no Santa, bullying, orphans, families losing their homes, and why there’s so many Santas because they have to have apprentices, have at it.  I believe the way these topics were addressed, plus all being in one movie, makes it dark, joyless, and devoid of Christmas spirit.  This movie even made Santa seem not so nice at times. 

Scoring: 1

Santa’s Boots (2018)

Rated: PG

Genres: Drama, Romance 

Starring: Megan Hilty, Noah Mills, and Teryl Rothery

Synopsis: Holly returns home for Christmas and is put to work as Santa’s elf at her family’s store, where she meets Nick, and falls in love. When Nick disappears days before Christmas, Holly searches for him with her only clue, his black boot. 

Review:  While the story has many of the classic components of a Christmas romance, the approach to them is something I haven’t seen before. I really enjoyed not knowing exactly how it would end. The cast, the story, and the setting were all wonderful. Keep an eye open for the nod to “Cinderella” at the end. 

Scoring: 4

 

Santa’s Little Helper (2015)
Rated: PG
Genres: Comedy, Fantasy 
Starring: Mike ‘The Miz’ Mizanin, AnnaLynne McCord, Eric Keenleyside
Synopsis: After getting fired from his job, a slick, fast-talking businessman, Dax, is thrown into an elf competition to become Santa’s next second-in-command. Put through a series of rigorous training exercises to prepare for the contest, Dax and another aspiring elf go head-to-head in the hopes of becoming Santa’s Little Helper.
Review:  While very silly (and you having to believe that Santa’s magic doesn’t tell him who to hire) this is still a fun romp. 
Scoring: 3